Read the TimesUnion.com article below, then post a comment in which you claim the Promise will be successful or unsuccessful, offer evidence from the article as well as outside information to support your claim, and logically connect the evidence to your position.
Once you have posted a comment, you are to reply to at least three other classmates’ original comments and one other classmate’s responses. Students that do not complete this during class may do so for homework by 9:00 PM on Tuesday, May 8, 2012.
A Promise for Better Futures
Albany Promise to announce major initiative for children attending the poorest schools
By Scott Waldman
Published 11:25 p.m., Sunday, May 6, 2012
ALBANY — The odds are stacked against them the day they are born.
The children who live in Albany's poorest neighborhoods are less likely to meet basic academic standards in English and math, less likely to finish high school and college, and less likely to pass their Regents exams.
They are more likely to become pregnant teenagers, more likely to miss school for unexcused absences, incarceration or suspension, and more likely to feel suicidal, according a report by a new educational consortium.
On Monday, the partnership, which is made up of 60 different stakeholders, will announce a major new effort to turn around the educational outcomes for the poorest children in Albany. Years in the making, it will target children in Arbor Hill, West Hill and the South End. The Albany Promise, as the group is calling itself, will draw on existing resources and a bundling of private donations, as well as state and federal grants, to help poor children receive the same opportunities in and out of school as their middle- and upper-class counterparts do.
Partners include the Albany school district, the city, the State University of New York, The College of Saint Rose, and many area nonprofits and businesses.
"We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out," SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimpher said.
She said Promise recognizes that this is a monumental task, one too vast to be accomplished by any one entity.
The Albany effort is partially modeled on Project Strive, a cradle-to-career effort Zimpher helped create that has expanded to sites around the country, and the Harlem Children's Zone, a New York City initiative that provides education as well as social and health services for children from birth until they enter the workforce. SUNY will create similar initiatives in other cities across the state.
The neighborhoods targeted by the new effort are the places in Albany where plywood covers many windows, where businesses have fled and where children are in need of a brighter future. They are not just at the epicenter of the city's poverty; they are also home to 9,000 children under age 18, including 2,500 under age 5, according to the new report produced by the consortium.
And the challenges faced by children in the city's poorest neighborhoods are profound. A quarter of Albany's children under 5 live in poverty, but in the neighborhoods targeted by the new effort, that number climbs to 60 percent, the report states.
The program is open to all children and families in the affected neighborhoods, regardless of where they attend school. Goals will be to prepare children for kindergarten, competency in core subjects, transition to high school, graduation from high school and entry into college or the workforce.
The goal is to create a pipeline of support for kids, mostly through uniting existing agencies, said Linda Jackson-Chalmers, assistant superintendent for community relations for Albany schools.
"It's a concept in order to support students in a successful life and career, it takes a whole village," she said.
Albany Promise will cost $500,000 to $750,000 annually and will eventually be housed at the Trinity Institute headquarters. The consortium has already raised $200,000 from private and corporate donors, including SEFCU and Turner Construction.
The first step will be to unite the city's diverse array of existing afterschool programs by bringing in leaders to decide on a narrow focus and common set of goals. Transportation will also be expanded to broaden participation by children in existing programs. There will also be more outreach to those who will be affected by the effort, said Barbara Smith, city councilwoman and a co-founder of the Albany Family Education Alliance.
Inspired by the Harlem Children's Zone, Smith and other concerned citizens and parents created a Baby Institute, where expectant mothers are prepared for the birth of their first child, and an after-school program focused on literacy.
"It's clear that fixing education and improving outcomes is not a simple proposition," she said. "It's very complex. We need different kinds of expertise focused on different aspects."
Smith said one of the priorities of the new effort will be getting input and participation from those who live in the affected neighborhoods. She said the Promise effort wants to create summer learning activities and access to extracurriculars that wealthier children experience throughout their school years.
Monday's announcement will include leaders in education, community, business, government and philanthropy and will be held from 9 to 11 a.m. at Giffen Memorial Elementary School. A second launch event will be held from 6 to 8 p.m. at Albany High School.
The promise made in the text above will be successful. In the text it says "We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out," SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimpher said". If you try, you will never fail.
ReplyDeletei agree with you gurdeep, once they see that they have the support they will come to realize that there are people that really care and this will bring success for the promise
DeleteI agree with you, Nancy is trying hard because in the article she gathered 200000$out of 750000$ for these kids. She is confident person and if she keeps on going she will be succssful.
DeleteI agree, strong efforts are being made to make sure the "Promise" is a sucess. With the help of the community we can make it happen.
Deleteyes, i agree because if they are getting the money from diffferent organizations they will be able to retrieve the money that will help these kids in getting the education they deserve.
DeleteIn the text above the promise will most likely be successful. In the text, it describes the steps/efforts that will be taken to help poor children get a good education. One of which is that it,"will draw on existing resources and a bundling of private donations, as well as state and federal grants, to help poor children receive the same opportunities in and out of school as their middle- and upper-class counterparts do." This means that they will try to raise money and receive generous donations that will help to give these kids living in poverty equal opportunities that other kids have as far as education goes, helping them in building a future/career.
ReplyDeletei agree with you alexus, you bring up some good points.
Deletei think that the contributions from corporate sponsors is an excellent way to provide resources to those in a disadvantaged area.
I agree with you both. I think when the kids see how much they are cared about they will want to try. Once those kids see that all these people want them to be successful they will try harder and want to go to high school and college
Deletei agree with you alexus because you should always want to draw kids to learn. i also like how you said most likely because you dont always know what could happen at the end of the day.
DeleteYou said that they will "try" to raise money for this program, but what happens when they don't? That money will have to come from everyone living in the city. The program won't last long on donations, and then who's to say everyone is willing to pay for this program when that does happen?
Deleteright but most likely "guiseppe" they will be able to fund the money because they are being funded by many different organizations.
DeleteGuiseppe you do have a great point but i feel that they will have enough money or they will get more organizations involved.
DeleteAfter reading this article, I think "the promise" has a good start. There are other programs like this and we can only hope that it wont fizzle out because funding won't continue or in THIS case corporate sponsors wont want to continue to keep programs like this going, but i think "the promise" will give them opportunities that they may have normally missed simply because they're poor.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you. Once this group stops getting mnoney it may fall but as long as it keeps getting money and has people going to it, it will be successful
DeleteI agree with Perri, after the money stops coming in the organization will fall. But I believe once people see what they are trying to do and how they are helping children better their education they will help out and donate more.
Deletei agree, hopefully these organizations will continue to fund this program that will help aide students get the education they deserve.
DeleteThe "Promise" will be successful if the funding there.Many programs like existed in the past but failed due to the fact funding stopped coming in to support the schools. I think it will successful because Nancy did lots of work for it and she seems to be a confident and determined person has shown from the text above.
DeleteThe Efforts they are making will be successful. In the Text it says "We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out," SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimpher said and in the group is made of 60 shareholders. Nancy raised 200000$ from privet donations and she needs 500,000$ to 750000$. Nancy raised 200000$ out of the total needed, she is a determined person and she most likely be successful has long she continues working has she been.
ReplyDeleteI agree she is doing a great job and I think with all the great ideas and all the steps she has she will get more people to donate money and help her with this program. As you can tell she really wants this to be successful and she will try her hardest to make sure of it.
DeleteI agree with you both. She has amazing ideas and really pushing forward to make sure nobody is left out. I feel the 200,000 dollar donations made by "SEFCU and Turner Construction," have helped significantly with the amount needed to fund the program.
DeleteI agree with all three of you. You guys make interesting points and you prove that they will be successful.
DeleteSo what do we do once that money has run out? The money will have to come out of our pockets, and many people can't afford that.
DeleteI agree with you Giuseppe. If this program doesn't success most likely it will come out of the tax payer's pocket. As long has Nancy can help support the promise then it will be successful and will help the cause and not cause harm to the country. In opinion, if she fails in gathering the money then i think the tax will come out of our pockets one way or other.
DeleteThe promise in the text above will be successful. It says "We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out." They have already made money for this program. As long as it keeps going on the road its going im sure it will be successful. The text explains the steps they are going to take to help the poor children of each city. This will help the kids and they will want to be successful when they get older.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you they will be successful once they keep raising money to help the kids and fouceson what they said they will do and they will be successful in every step.
DeleteI agree that with this program the child that live in the ghetto will have a changed life. By the means of the program they can grow in a healthy environment and learn and we all know the education foreshadows what you are in the States. This program gives them aid in something they need that we take for advantage everyday.
DeleteThe Promise In The Text Above Will Be Very Successful Im My Opinion."On Monday, the partnership, which is made up of 60 different stakeholders, will announce a major new effort to turn around the educational outcomes for the poorest children in Albany. Years in the making, it will target children in Arbor Hill, West Hill and the South End. The Albany Promise, as the group is calling itself, will draw on existing resources and a bundling of private donations, as well as state and federal grants, to help poor children receive the same opportunities in and out of school as their middle- and upper-class counterparts do." This Means That Albany Is Making A Huge Effort To Make Albany A Better Place For Kids In The Comunitties And Making A Huge Effort To Give Those Kids A Better Education And A Better Future.
ReplyDeletei agree with you michelle, the more effort they make, the more money they recieve and the more work they put into it, it will become more successful.
DeleteI agree with you nyla about them recieving more money, the more effort they make, but the government can only hand out so much money, and why would they spend so much money on just one city?
DeleteThe "Promise" made in the article will be successful. In the text above it focuses on children who a struggling in school due to other things going on in their outside lives. The article states "The neighborhoods targeted by the new effort are the places in Albany where plywood covers many windows, where businesses have fled and where children are in need of a brighter future," meaning they are trying to help those who need it the most. By taking these steps to better the children they will have a brighter career and a chance at a better future.
ReplyDeleteI agree with what you said. They are going to be succesfull, they are going to take the correct steps for being successful.
DeleteI aggree with you that they will be successful and once they keep doing what they said they will everything will be find.
DeleteI agree they will be succssful in making these kids getting a better education and a better life away from the dangerous enviroment they live in right now. They have money coming in and they plan sounds solid. they are doing a good job and if they keep it up they might get those kids out of the hood.
DeleteI agree with what you said. Most of what you said sounds really logical and was structured well.
ReplyDeleteThe artice above talk about the promise Ablany has made.I think that it will be successful. It stated that "We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out. And plus they have already raise money for this program and other colleges are working with them to make this a success.
ReplyDeletei dont understand how EVERY child can be succesful its just not possible
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe promise in the text above would be successful . It is worried about children who struggle is school because of other things going on.the text says that they will be with every child every step of the way.they have already fundraised the money for this program. i feel this is a great opportunitiy for the kids who cant afford things.
ReplyDeleteI believe that the Albany Promise shown in the text above will be very successful. Kids in those areas where they dont have a lot need to be shown that they have support in their lives to push them and keep them going. Once they come to realize that they have the support they will want to strive to be better and they can help to support other and pass it a long. In the text, "A quarter of Albany's children under 5 live in poverty," but, "We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out," SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimpher said." They are helping as much as they can and this is what they need to make that change. This will make it more successful.
ReplyDeleteI agree. Kids will want to do good then their friends will want to do good too. The more the support the better. They need to show the kids that they care about their lives.
DeleteThe "Promise" stated in the text above will most likely be sucessful. It is giving the kids a future that they would never have had. It gives the children a positive future to look forward to. If the kids have a better education, they will want to learn to have a better future.
ReplyDeleteBut how are we supposed to afford this? We are having budget cuts as it is, so there is no money for us to make this happen.
DeleteI agree this program as good intentions. But, What happens when the money they need runs out. They need over $500,000 ever year. This could a cause for more debt in the States. in my opinion this program will be a good thing but if only they can support themselves and not depend on others. When you depend on others you don't have a guarantee for what get and you can have a chance of getting something you dislike.
DeleteThe "Promise" stated in the text above will most likely be successful. The Albany Promise wants to improve the educational outcome of Albany's poorest children by bringing them up to academic standards through various programs. They intend to fund this through private donations, existing resources, and state and federal grants. Annually the program will cost from $500,000 to $750,000. To this day $200,000 has been raised. The success of this program depends on one thing, the money. If all the money comes in, then all those dreams can become a reality for these children.
DeleteI think the "Promise" will be unsuccessful. In the article,A Promise for Better Futures, it states that "Albany Promise will cost $500,000 to $750,000 annually and will eventually be housed at the Trinity Institute headquarters." Our city already doesn't have enough money for the basic neccesities, so how are we supposed to afford this? I think it's a good idea, but i don't think it will work because of the expense.
ReplyDeleteI disagree, If adults want a better future for their children they will do more to make it happen. Children are our first priority.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteI agree with you this just doesnt make sense part of the reason we are in debt is because no one can do what they gotta do to get out of high school and proceed to college.
Deletei disagree, because there is already money invested into this program. most adults want to see kids become successful so they will try there hardest to make it happen.
Deletei see this as a great leap foward towards our youth and a great investment into thier future. By doing this albany will be a better place in the future with less crime and more prosperety thanks to people like SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimpher
ReplyDeleteI agree, with better advancements in the community it will raise the value and reputation of Albany. In the future more will come if this will be sucessful.
DeleteI agree with you. The students that dont have has much Stuff has me and you do, will now have a change their futures because they have people that care for their education and the people have the meaning for the education. Has time goes by more and more people will give money because they will see the change going on.
ReplyDeleteClaim:I believe this "Promise" can only go so far.
ReplyDeleteEvidence:"We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out," SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimpher said.
Logic:This qoute gets to me in a way because if no ones left out who is gonna do all of the jobs with less income? The people that choose not to do well in school and mess up is the people that will be at the drivethru in Dunkin Donuts its just the honest truth. not everyone canbe a millioniare because then no one would be...
i definetily agree with you both, it will be successful when they put all their time into it. More kids will get the education that they need and they will realize that they can keep going to make themselves better.
ReplyDeletei think the "promise" will be successful, because they are trying too not leave anyone behind. in the text it says "We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out," SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimpher said. it also said "The Albany Promise, as the group is calling itself, will draw on existing resources and a bundling of private donations, as well as state and federal grants, to help poor children receive the same opportunities in and out of school as their middle- and upper-class counterparts do" so they are getting the same treatment as other kids and the same oppertunity. this is a positive thing that i hope they can keep going on with.
ReplyDeleteI feel that the promise will be unsuccessful. In this article, its explaining how "We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out," But infact, it is most likely impossible to basically force people to try. If you are the type of person to not try, then its waisting others people time and money to try to get the lazy ones working, or trying in school. Its your choice in life if you wanna go somewhere. Its so hard to get a stable job without a good education. Trying to get people to do something they dont wanna do is gonna be too hard to accomplish. If you dont wanna try, have fun working at McDonalds for the rest of your career. lol
ReplyDeleteI believe the "promise" could work, if people are willing to cooperate. Giving these children this opportunity is very fortunate for them, but what if they decide not to go to this program? You can't force them, this "promise" would be a waste of time and money.
ReplyDeleteThe text illustrates a positive influence on the city of Albany. I personally believe that this promise will be successful. On Monday, “stakeholders will announce a major new effort to turn around the educational outcomes for the poorest children in Albany.” The plan that they’re presenting has a many ideas that could be supportive towards the children of Albany. The only thing that scares me is how slow the progress might be. Even though Nancy Zimpher said, "We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out,” that could take a lot of time and make peoples hopes up but ending in a bad result. Other wise that, they have a lot of back up plans and it seems like it could be extremely successful and a major help. This commitment can be inspiring even if it does fail and still encourage a change.
ReplyDeleteI believe if they really are interested in getting the kids the education they deserve then the program will continue, but if they're not then it's like why waste your time by offering to fund something if within a few years or so your just going to stop the funding.
ReplyDeleteThe claim the “Promise” will probably be successful. In the text it says “We are going to work together to make sure every child, every step of the way, experiences success and nobody is left out”, also in another part in the text it says “Albany promise will cost $500,000 to $750,000 annually” and also says “ The Consortium has already raised $200,000”. The “promise” will most likely be successful because Nancy is very determined. She is determined because from $500,000 to $750,000 she collected $200,000 from private and corporate donors. From my experiences people don’t really like to donate. Getting donations is hard and she collected $200,000 and also she is doing this hard work for poor kids. She is a determined person doing this for the better cause but has long has much is coming in the program will be successful but when the money goes the chance of accomplishing they goals will decrease in percent. I say this due to the fact in our society the more money you have the better chance you have to accomplish something.
ReplyDelete